
Ethics Council Chairman backs voting against AfD-members on medical ethics in Bundestag debates
The chairman of the Ethics Council, Helmut Frister, states that there should not be hesitation to vote for bio- and medical ethical motions in the Bundestag merely because the AfD members are aligned against a majority.
Frister told the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (Friday edition) that it is possible "that in a vote where the party mandate has been lifted, a majority can be achieved through votes cast by the AfD." He said this scenario should not prevent the Bundestag from pursuing such a vote, otherwise, it would deprive itself of the opportunity to vote on medical ethical issues outside of party mandates.
Fundamentally, he supports not aligning with the AfD. "I consider the brick wall against the AfD appropriate, but it only applies to votes where there is a party mandate," Frister stated. In votes based solely on individual conscience, he believes this wall should not be applied.
Martin Sichert, the health policy spokesperson for the AfD parliamentary group, told the newspaper that his group holds differing views regarding the upcoming vote on non-invasive prenatal tests, while expressing a unified rejection regarding a potential opt-out solution for organ donation. When asked about bio- and medical ethical issues, he claimed, "Fundamentally, every deputy is committed to their conscience; there is no party constraint, at least not in the AfD."
Deputies from the Union, SPD, and The Greens announced that they would not actively seek collaboration with AfD members even on ethical questions. CSU politician Stephan Pilsinger is part of a parliamentary group preparing a motion on "Maintaining Voluntariness" for organ donation. Regarding the AfD, he said in reference to the motion: "We are not talking to them, and we are not doing anything with them." Nevertheless, he noted that "this party represents 24 percent of the deputies and can ultimately be decisive in such matters." He assumed that AfD deputies would also understand such votes as decisions of conscience.
Sabine Dittmar (SPD), who advocates for the opt-out solution, whereby donation willingness is presumed after brain death, said: "At the AfD, there is no chance of approval on this topic, that is clearly recognizable-that is why we did not even seek approval from them. I would not even know which members of the faction to approach on this topic." Her group also invited MPs and employees of the AfD to an information event. She does not expect their support. "In democratic factions, we need the support of about 70 percent; we orient ourselves by that," said Dittmar.
Corinna Rüffer (Greens) advocates for a review of the reimbursement for non-invasive prenatal tests used to detect Trisomies in unborn babies. "No one strives for majorities on such issues with the AfD, where leading figures express anti-disability sentiment," she said. Since she expects a broad majority for her motion, she does not assume that the AfD's behavior will play any role. She admitted, however, that the many mandates of the AfD complicate the formation of a majority. "Of course, it matters when a quarter of the MPs cannot be considered for screening-if you want such an interfactional motion to pass, you count heads," said Rüffer. "And that will not be easy."











