
BSW Chief De Masi calls Karlsruhe ruling "scandalous" and "self-sabotage" after Federal Constitutional Court rejects BSW election review complaint
BSW party chairman Fabio De Masi criticized the Federal Constitutional Court's rejection of the BSW's election review complaint as "scandalous" and a "self-demolition" for the highest German court. Speaking to Redaktionsnetzwerk Deutschland, he said: "It is scandalous that the Federal Constitutional Court rejects our complaint without oral proceedings. This is a self-demolition for the highest German court."
The judges in Karlsruhe could have demonstrated that they rule "politically independently." De Masi complains that such a well-substantiated election review complaint and such an extremely narrow result have never happened before. He argues that the BSW cannot be accused of lacking evidence, yet they are foregoing a request for data from the electoral authorities and oral proceedings and evidence gathering.
The BSW leader called for reforms in election dispute law. He told the RND: "We need a new election dispute law in Germany so that such procedures do not take so long. If an election result comes out so tight, it must automatically be recounted in the future."
In contrast, The Left welcomed the Federal Constitutional Court's decision. Sören Pellmann, the leader of The Left parliamentary group, told the Rheinische Post (Thursday): "We are pleased that the Federal Constitutional Court shares our legal opinion and the opinion of the Bundestag by rejecting the BSW's election review complaint as inadmissible today." He added that the BSW had not presented any election errors, but had relied until the end on "assumptions, speculation, and mere assertions." He expressed hope that "they will accept the decision of the Federal Constitutional Court and stop now."
Meanwhile, Berlin law professor Sophie Schönberger warned the BSW against "conspiracy theories." She told the Rheinische Post: "What can happen now, is naturally that the BSW simply continues in public and continues to indulge the conspiracy theories that everything is corrupt." The legal scholar warned: "We have already seen this from the AfD, and it is naturally an overall worrying development for democracy."
The BSW had previously failed with its election review complaint against the February 2025 Bundestag election. According to Wednesday's statements, the Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe dismissed it as inadmissible.











