
Germany has responsibility for climate damages; Victims may be entitled to compensation from industrial nations
People who are losing their livelihoods due to the climate catastrophe may have a right to compensation from industrialized nations. This conclusion was reached by a new legal opinion from the Hamburg firm Günther, commissioned by Greenpeace. The legal opinion is based on the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling of July 23, 2025, which for the first time classified climate protection duties as binding.
This right can also mean opening legal avenues for people who are losing their livelihoods due to climate effects. The legal opinion concludes that compensation for quantifiable damages, such as reconstruction and the provision of aid to displaced people, is possible. However, the opinion also suggests a national legal framework for people who are losing their livelihoods due to climate effects as a suitable form of redress. Such a framework does not currently exist: the Geneva Refugee Convention does not directly cover climate effects.
How such a legal framework would look is left to Germany; international law makes no provisions for this. Furthermore, the ban on deportation applies: no one may be sent back to a country where their life faces a real risk. Deportations to climate catastrophe areas must therefore be excluded, according to the lawyers.
The legal opinion assumes that Germany is violating its climate protection obligations. Greenpeace believes that Germany does not meet the strict standard of due diligence set by the ICJ and that Germany's CO2 budget is exhausted. The standard is strict: every state must do its utmost to adhere to the legally binding 1.5-degree limit of the Paris Agreement. While the financing of climate damage and adaptation measures is also being discussed at the UN climate conference in Antalya this week, the new legal opinion expands the scope of compensation for climate damages significantly.
"The federal government must financially support affected countries and protect people whose livelihoods are lost due to the climate crisis," said Fawad Durrani, Greenpeace expert on climate and migration. "Cutting climate finance is the wrong path and must be changed. Cooperation and support in climate protection are also an opportunity to build new and stable partnerships in an increasingly polarized world order."











